Taxe habitation logement vacant : avis d'imposition sur un bureau avec vue sur Lyon

French housing tax in 2024: 1.2 million homes may have been taxed in error

A report by France’s Inspectorate General of Finance (IGF) documents errors in the taxes on second homes and vacant properties. It also explains why owners have struggled to declare who occupies each home.

Of the 4.6 million homes assessed under the remaining housing taxes in 2024, the IGF estimates that 1.2 million may have been taxed in error. This total covers second homes as well as vacant properties.

A significant figure, reminding property owners of the importance of verifying the declared occupation status for each of their real estate assets.

Why did so many housing tax assessments go wrong?

Since the removal of the housing tax on primary residences, the administration must distinguish properties based on their actual status: primary residence, secondary residence, vacant property, rented property, or property occupied free of charge.

Since 2023, much of this information has come from “Gérer mes biens immobiliers”, the property service in the owner’s online tax account.

The IGF found significant problems with the new system and an increase in the cost of correcting assessments.

The situation is not always easy to assess: change of tenant, period of vacancy between rentals, short-term furnished rental, secondary residence, or property managed by a property management company.

A missing piece of information or an incorrectly classified situation can have consequences for the calculation of the tax.

What owners should check

The issue of the housing tax for vacant property illustrates the importance for each property owner to ensure that the information recorded by the administration accurately reflects the real occupation status of their property.

At each change of occupation, it is necessary to verify that the information held by the administration accurately reflects the current status of the property.

It is especially important to pay attention to:

  • the nature of the property’s occupation;
  • the start and end dates of occupation;
  • any periods of vacancy;
  • the identity of the occupants when required to be provided;
  • and the specific information requested when the property is subject to a seasonal or furnished rental.

The tax authority asks owners to report changes of occupancy in “Gérer mes biens immobiliers”.

What to do when a tax appears unjustified?

Receiving a tax notice does not necessarily mean the amount is finally due.

If a notice relates to a property treated as vacant, first check which tax it concerns and which occupancy dates the tax authority used.

This process can be carried out directly through the secure messaging system of the fiscal space.

It is useful to have documents demonstrating the actual occupancy status of the property: lease agreement, evidence of occupancy, or any other relevant documentation.

A challenge does not automatically suspend payment. Where appropriate, you can request a payment deferral at the same time.

Should property owners expect a new tax?

No.

This is an important point because some proposals in the report could easily lead to excessive interpretations.

The IGF considers several options, from simplifying declarations to a much broader proposal for an additional property tax charge from the second property owned.

However, these are merely exploratory ideas. No such new tax has been adopted.

The report primarily establishes a finding: the current system is complex, costly to administer, and generates a large number of errors.

Furnished rental: maintain a clear occupancy status

For property owners who rent out their apartment as a furnished property, this report also emphasizes the importance of precise management of occupancy periods.

Temporary rental, mobility lease, rental for several months or intermediate periods: these different situations must be documented if the administration requires justification for the use of the property.

With 2BeApart, we keep records of stays and occupancy periods for the apartments we manage.

Owners remain responsible for their tax declarations. When needed, we can provide the occupancy records we hold for their apartment.

A tax regime that has become more complex for landlords

The figure of 1.2 million homes incorrectly taxed does not mean that all taxes should be challenged.

It demonstrates that a landlord now has a strong interest in verifying the information held by the administration about their properties.

In an increasingly complex fiscal and regulatory environment, the quality of information on the actual occupancy of the property becomes almost as important as property management itself.

For Lyon landlords who wish to explore a temporary furnished rental solution and a professional property management of their apartment, the 2BeApart team can naturally assess the property’s situation.

PreviousVacant homes tax in Lyon in 2027: what owners should know
NextRental investment in Lyon: how do rent caps affect returns?